Who’s calling whose bluff?
By Ooi Kee Beng
SEPT 20 — Millions of Malaysian eyes were focused on Sept 16 this week. That day has now come and gone, and the government is still in power despite opposition leader Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim’s claim that he has the means to fell Premier Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi’s administration.
He had asked that day to meet the Prime Minister in order to provide the latter with the names of parliamentarians willing to cross over to his coalition, the Pakatan Rakyat. But Abdullah refused, asserting that Anwar was merely seeking to gain political mileage out of such a meeting.
But what if Anwar isn’t bluffing?
If that is the case, and his use of the date of Sept 16 to destabilise the government and lure East Malaysian MPs to his side has actually succeeded, then Malaysia is in a transitional stage where PR is working out the details of how the handover of power can best take place without violence and without the Internal Security Act being used on more of its members.
Then, the first date to watch would be Sept 24, when Anwar appears in court to face his sodomy charge again. He will be tempted to have things over and done with by that time to minimise risks for himself personally.
The government’s hasty release of journalist Tan Chee Hoon and Selangor state assemblywoman Teresa Kok, both surprisingly arrested under the ISA last week, shows that Abdullah does not have good control over his Cabinet, and that Umno’s supreme council is doing damage control and trying to focus on Anwar. Had Kok not been released, a new crisis would have built up within the ruling coalition.
Next, there is Oct 12, when Parliament returns from its uncustomary Ramadan break. The Budget will be hotly debated then, but also the government’s use of the ISA.
And once Parliament is in session, and if Anwar has not been bluffing, then he and his allies are at liberty to move for a no-confidence motion against Abdullah’s Cabinet. Should Parliament pass the motion and if BN respects the constitution, then the Abdullah government will step down and the King will have to appoint someone else to form a functioning government with majority support in Parliament.
What could also happen — and this seems most likely if things do come this far — is that the King decides to dissolve the eight-month-old Parliament and call for new elections, which need not affect governments at the state level.
But what if Anwar is not bluffing, and Mr Abdullah knows it but is pulling a bluff of his own to gain time, parrying every move that Anwar can make to carry out his threat, until he himself is ready to make the next move in this extended drama?
Then Malaysia may expect to see draconian measures taken against the opposition, with Abdullah and his Cabinet doing all they can to crush the opposition parties. The ISA would then be widely used.
Given how five states are governed by the opposition today, such a move by Abdullah would be the least wise of the few alternatives he has at his disposal. It would also break up the BN for good.
But if Anwar is indeed bluffing, and if he has failed to persuade enough lawmakers from the ruling BN to defect, then the situation is one — at least in Parliament — where the majority will continue ruling, but with no real possibility of amending the Constitution. It will also have to deal with a very loud and bold opposition of 81 MPs snapping at its heels throughout the remainder of its five-year mandate.
It will also be an opposition that will aggressively seek to topple the BN every chance it gets.
If Anwar is bluffing, then this scenario will be the most stable for the country in the near future. Umno will go on to solve its leadership problems as best it can, perhaps by Dec 16 or 17 at its general assembly. Otherwise, Abdullah will leave in time, supposedly earlier than mid-2010, with his deputy Datuk Seri Najib Razak’s camp — in tandem with the increasing speed at which it will be handed more power — edging him out faster than he might imagine.
Within Umno may grow a Najib-Khairy Jamaluddin camp to limit rising internal opposition from an increasingly confident Datuk Mukhriz Mahathir and his allies.
Umno, by then controlling BN without any pretence at consensual decision making, will hang on to power ... at least until the next general election.
However, at least in the longer term, given how diverse political representation has become in Malaysia, we may expect a more decentralised form of federalism with different parties entrenched in different states, and a looser form of coalitional culture at the centre.
The central-line type of political “debate”, if that had ever been the right word to use, will dissipate in time, along with the notion that ruling coalitions are forever. — TODAY
The Insider will cover the issues of the day, politics, business, lifestyle, sports and entertainment. We hope that in time more Malaysians who crave for balanced and serious reporting on issues will contribute their news and views to us. We believe that with transparency, promotion of good character and professionalism, we will contribute towards building a country that has the USP (U-unity, S-security and P-prosperity) to be transformed into a great nation.
The Malaysian Insider values your thoughtful opinions on any reports or analyses contained here. Please refrain from comments of a racist, sexist, vulgar or derogatory nature and note that comments can be edited, rewritten for clarity or to avoid questionable issues. We also reserve the right to delete off-topic comments. Occasionally we may have presented an article with typographical errors that may lead to a completely different meaning or thought. This is not intentional and we would appreciate your feedback as and when this happens.
If you would like to get regular updates on news join The Malaysian Insider Facebook Group.
This site is best viewed with Firefox.